This topic was last updated by  The New Guy at 06/07/2017 07:45 pm

  • Author
    Posts
  • #1024

    speedvoltage
    Participant
    Over the past 14 years, I have been level designing a lot of levels, many for fun and testing purposes and others for public and competitive servers.
    dm_basebunker, which you can find at http://gamebanana.com/maps/191622 is the last map I released at this time and is the most detailed level I designed for 1on1 competitive.
    What I also learnt is that the levels I design tend to suit more public servers/fun servers rather than competitive servers. Speaking with many players and receiving feedback on the very few mapping competitions I participated, I found out that my levels were cluttered and did not play smoothly on a competitive standard.

    Therefore, after some planning and drawing some new concepts, my question is what makes you love the maps you play on usually?
    If I manage to gather enough data as to why you like those maps, I will surely be able to design more suitable levels that match competitive standards.

    Thanks for reading,
    speedvoltage
    #1030

    Maxtasy
    Participant
    Here my opinion on good hl2dm maps for 1v1 and 2v2:
    Have a center area with some important resources, like super charger or an RPG (use some mechanic to get the RPG that takes a little bit of time like on bio or caverns and that notifies all players that RPG is about to get taken). Have 1 or 2 spawns in this main area maximum. This area should be approachable from different angles but should also not bee too open. Around this center area you have different smaller areas with resources. Here you will have the majority of spawn points. All these areas should be connected by hallways etc. so you have several options to move around the map. A good reference is the layout of Caverns or Lockdown_r6, Lostvillage. Avoid having huge open areas or hallways that are too narrow. Two playermodels side by side should fit into each hallway.
    After cou have this basic layout think about having a little variety in hight. I would add some underground path/area like in caverns. And maybe some higher ground, ledges that connect them. Keep this at a minimum though, you don't want to make the map too complex. It's always easier to add stuff into the map in later stages after some playtesting.

    Personally I devide weapons and items into different categories and place them accordingly. My rule of thumb for a good amount of weapons for 1v1/2v2 maps is:

    Basics:
    3 Shotguns
    2 Magnums
    Some grenades and weapon ammo scattered around the map

    Advanced:
    1 Crossbow
    1 AR2 along with an orb nearby

    Premiums:
    RPG as described above
    4 SMG grenades located in less obvious places
    2 more orbs located in less obvious places
    2 RPG ammos located further away from the center to encourage a less campy playstyle (really depends if your map is RPG centered).

    HP and suit batteries should be evenly scattered around the map. Not really important in the earlier stages of the map and can be fine tuned later on.

    Once all this is done, think about the theme of the map. IMO a great theme that sgould be put into a map is some sort of Portal theme. Especially the partially destroyed Portal chambers. The white surfaces are good contrast to the player models and it looks clean. The occasional "overgrown"  and destroyed bits of the map will make it even better. I hope this gives you some inspiration.

    Here a reference picture (ofcourse the map shouldnt be as cluttered)


    If you have any further questions I'm happy to answer them! :)
    #1046

    The New Guy
    Moderator

    First, allow me to say thank you for braving an attempt at 'professional style’ environment-creation in this rather complicated and obscure game. So – and I am pretty sure I can speak for all hl2dm players when I say this – thank you very much for any future efforts and new maps you put forth.


    Before I start my extensive (nearly pedantic) reply, I feel I should point out to everyone that hl2dm was a game that Valve never wanted to make. The people who have posted thus far are probably aware of this, but for everyone who doesn't know, there was absolutely zero-effort to make hl2 multiplayer until the Half-Life 2 source code was hacked from Valve’s servers. His name was Axel Gembe, and he leaked the source code to HL2 either on, or shortly before, October 3rd, 2003. Besides the alleged “250 million” USD worth of damages, people within the Half-Life 1 Deathmatch community saw, what they felt, was a glaring concern. No multiplayer support had been developed, and the game was reportedly (aka “rumored to be”) due to release a mere 4-6 months from when the source-code was leaked. The only multiplayer game being developed at that point was Counter-Strike: Source, which Valve later confirmed would be released with HL2 single-player as the ‘featured’ multiplayer. This, as all of us here could expect, did not go over will with HL1DM players, Quakers, or fans of any arena shooter.


    So, what did Valve do? Well, they found some Half-Life 1 modder, who was already modding the single-player code to allow for multiplayer on his own (rumors say,) and made him the ONLY coder and gave him only one project manager to work with.


    That’s it. Two people. That was the ‘Official’ Development team.

    They did receive some logistical support from Valve for Source-engine-wide issues, however.


    It only grew (slightly) in support when Verizon announced their “FiOS Grand Tournament,” which was a winner-take-all American 1v1 league. I didn’t start playing until Spring 2007, so I can’t provide more reliable info when compared to some other members of this website. Feel free to ask them, should you desire learning more of the fumbled beginnings of this broken game.


    With all that being said, the reason this game has such broken mechanics and strange diversity of maps (regardless of what sub-sect of the community you go to) is because this game’s very existence reminds Gabe & company what Axel Gembe did to them. They had spent at least 5 years already on the development of their HL2 masterpiece, and in the long run, the hack made the game better. Valve addressed the ‘unforseen’ feedback of the ‘hacked’ game quite well and polished Half-Life 2 in an amazing fashion. But, they don’t remember all that too fondly; Valve likely only remembers the anguish of the violation of their property and the ‘adult’ use of their player models on image-boards. By the time this hack happened, Valve was likely already in the High-Concept (aka Design-Document or ‘drawing board’) stages of Team Fortress 2’s development, and – given Valve’s proven track record of foresight – probably already saw how skill-based Arena games were on the decline. The only way to get good at an Arena Shooter is to lose (quite often) to better players (in a respectful manner,) and the ‘larger’ market hates losing. Any COD game released after HL2 will provide evidence of the larger masses throwing a ‘hissy-fit’ in this regard.


    Why the rant on the troubled beginnings of HL2DM in a mapping thread? Because anytime someone tries to say that a certain feature of a map goes against an established rule, guideline, or ‘cannon’ of HL2DM’s core gameplay, you can simply – perhaps respectfully – tell that person to eat a bag of genitals (ie; dicks and such.)


    If not for the brief attention FiOS gave the game, I doubt Valve would have patched numerous “extreme” bugs this game had up until that point. Apparently it was easy to use the mousewheel and become a “gravity-gun tornado” and who knows what else. Fact is: Valve loathed this project. They did the bare minimum and didn’t really care about balance or establishing true game-play mechanics. As such, ALL good mapping trends were, and still are, player-driven.




    → tl;dr:

    My apologies to Dallas, Maxtasy, and anyone else who are already well-versed in this game’s unfortunate history. This game could have been the best Arena Shooter ever made, but alas, the only thing ‘good’ in this game is up to us – the players and inspired amateurs.


    So, the majority of issues you will encounter in this game/engine are not your fault, but great maps find ways to overcome all of HL2DM’s bullcrap nuances.




    Now, onto the original question(s) of this thread:


    Section 1.) The crux of any ‘good’ map is how it transitions between ‘levels’ or ‘floors.’

    Section 2.) After that, the control balance, for this defines the ‘theme’ of a given map; the currently established control items would be the Super-Charger, the RPG, and (half the time) the Ar2.

    Section 3.) And lastly, how close the map holds-up to the “NewGuy load-out” formulas, and if the map has a proper “gathering flow.”


    And actually, as of dm_fraggin_v4, there is a ‘new’ control item (player-made of course, thank you Kakujitsu) called the “Lambda-Health” which is essentially a +(200) HP mega-health that re-spawns @ 65 seconds. We get a lot of blow-back from this ‘change’ to the game-play of HL2DM, but I just tell those players to chow-down on some genitals. Any inspired mapper or developer owes absolutely nothing to the ‘original’ idea of HL2DM. Anything can & should be tried and/or judged based on it’s merits – not preconceptions.


    So, before I go talking about my personal ‘guidelines’ and such, remember to never be afraid to cut-lose and try something bold & new in the map(s) you make for us.


    If it works, great. If it doesn’t – we still thank you for the attempt.


    Anywho...


    ------------------------------------------------------

    Section 1: Map Transitions

    ------------------------------------------------------

    Simply put, maps that only have one ‘floor’ just don’t work out. I would imagine that may have been a ‘gripe’ you received from some play-testers who played your posted work in this thread. Maps like “gm_flatgrass” would never work in competition – and besides the fact that particular map is devoid of any features – a competitive map that is simply ‘flat’ just cannot allow for the type of variety, depth, or enthralling game-play that is required for any kind of Arena FPS.


    The exact variety of transitions a given map uses to transit players from one level/area to another and how reliable those transitions prove to be are the quintessential ‘foundation’ of any ‘good’ map. Transitions are like tools used to complete your ‘job’ of allowing players to flow from one area of a map to another. Each situation has the best tool for a given job. Sure, you can shove long ladders in a map, and those ladders might make it barely playable (like in dm_ethic by VitaminG;) but, a short-range, one-way teleport that accounts for aggressive, close-range combat with a ‘drop hole’ would work much better.


    After you have begun to settle on a layout for your map – paying no heed to texturing or lighting at this point (ie; orange walls) – your next step is to ‘tool’ the transitions you think you need for the varying situations your map is facing you with. It is a lot of trial-n-error at this point, which is why I would recommended not thinking about weapon/item placement (aka loadout) at all. You should not even begin to think about how your map will be “loaded out” until you feel your transitions are tooled correctly. The only items you would pay any mind to at this stage would be the “control items” that I mentioned previously, but if you find that a certain type of transition is just not working for a given area of your map – no matter how much you try to ‘tool’ it to the given situation – you may need to change where you thought a Super-Charger or RPG would go. Allow yourself a lot of flexibility at this stage, for play-testers may find that a given mechanic you were hoping for simply won’t work out. This is why a lot of competitive hl2dm maps fail – because players either don’t accurately convey or don’t realize that a particular type of transition or ‘map-mechanic’ won’t become playable. And then, after the mapper has moved on to building upon this foundation, they find out later (usually at the prefinal stage) that they would need to perform a complete rebuild of ‘base brushwork’ in order to make something so critical to the environment ‘work.’ And of course, after you spend hours tuning textures & lighting all over a given interactive environment – a rebuild of a map is the LAST thing you would want to do; after this realization, the project immediately stalls and then usually dies. There is not much fun to be had in such a situation. Do everything you can to avoid such a thing, and it will likely require a great deal of caution and patience.



    Some silly anecdotal pseudo-evidence of this: when I was helping Abnoksious make dm_airfusion, I strongly advised him to keep the map un-textured (using the dev/orange textures of course) for almost 2 months. During this time I pressured a lot of EE members to play the darn thing, and they obliged. After the original layout of the map was almost cut in half, the final version began to take shape. Yes – non-NA players who think the map is too big for a 1v1 (morons) – the map at one time had 50% more layout/complexity on the other side of the ‘RPG-speed-tunnel.’ To be clear, the stated ‘objective’ of the 2nd HL2DM-University mapping contest was looking for a map that was “Fast enough for a 1v1, but big enough for team-play.” Misha was worried that my suggested ‘gutting’ of the original layout would make it too small for team-play, but thankfully, his beautiful architecture was very easy to mold and culture at that stage of development because he was clever enough to leave all aesthetics and art direction on paper at that point. After the resounding positive feedback from the testers to the change in layout, I advised him to leave the map orange & barren longer than he initially planned. During this time he only worked on the ‘speed tunnel’ and ‘air-ladder’ transitions. They are still not perfect, but it was a bold new idea for hl2dm in the year 2010. I told him how if those transitions couldn’t be made to work consistently, the map would lose. It was also around this time that we realized that no manner of ‘jump-pad’ was going to work in the ‘main’ area of the map despite how badly I wanted to emulate the ‘core’ transition found on dm_feudal, so Misha had to re-tool the area and used an elevator/lift that functioned like an amalgamation of the similar-minded transitions found on dm_lostarena & dm_biohazard. So, players can fly around that main area as intended, but you have to wait for the lift to reset and cannot purse targets as quickly or dynamically as we both initially hoped. Despite the game being 7 years older, its functional ability has only become worse with regards to mapping mechanics. It is very likely that all hopeful mappers of HL2DM will be asked to make compromises like this.



    Granted, the play-testing of the judges was not anywhere near as strenuous as the ‘competitive scrims’ of the larger player base in the months or years following the contest, but Misha worked hard at those map-mechanics and ultimately won the contest. His map was not as ‘pretty’ as dm_helix at the time, but it was new and fast. People later saw all the beauty Misha had planned in dm_airfusion_final – but had he worked on those aesthetics during the contest and NOT the bold new transitions, he would have lost. While the map was still ‘orange’ we spoke at length about the loadout of the map. Misha’s favorite map at the time was dm_biohazard, so he made the map fit that competitive theme that he was inspired by. As such, the entirety of the control times (Super charger + RPG) is in a central ‘main’ area. But, that is only one possible combination. In another underrated map like dm_minelab, the Ar2 + RPG is pitted ‘against’ the higher ground which holds the Super-Charger, whereas in the overrated dm_lockdown, the theme is the Ar2 vs everything else. Caverns also has the same theme as lockdown, even though there is the illusion that the RPG is on the ‘low ground’ away from the Super-Charger; if a team is not in-control of the high ground, they likely will not be able to establish an RPG possession. This is why I encouraged Kakujitsu to make the ‘lambda-health’ so that we all could have another piece of this ‘control puzzle’ to play with and grant more possibilities for competitive maps.



    Hmm, I suppose this latest bit can serve as a proper segue to my next section of this book-long post.




    ------------------------------------------------------

    Section 2: Control Balance

    ------------------------------------------------------

    This idea isn’t too terribly complicated. As I mentioned before, when you begin to finalize your layout and transitions, you need to begin to see how you map is taking shape and then decide how you want the control of your map to play-out. If your map is to be for 1v1 only, you should never place more than a single Ar2 in the map. Then, as it currently stands now, you decide if you want your map to have a Super-Charger or RPG or both. Yes, there are maps like dm_lostarena that have neither, but to be fair, Sw0t wanted that map to have a full-on Mega-Health, but was told not to do so by a certain admin of CAL at the time. I would prefer not to mention who that was. Needless to say, this particular person deserves a heavy (forced) diet of genitals for numerous reasons other than this “no mega” edict. Sw0t was told something along the lines of “if the game was meant to have instant-pickups, Valve would have created some to work within the game in a native fashion” or something along those lines. This was also the same guy that told Valar not to use ‘fast-ladders;’ these are invisible and compressed ‘stairs’ that proved to be superior to ‘stock’ or ‘single-player’ ladders in every way. This unnamed person was quite the dense and out-of-touch community leader (or tyrant.) But, as my earlier tirade drove home – Valve didn’t care much for this game or any ‘pr0s’ that would play it. As such, attempting to devise the ‘divine will’ Valve had for HL2DM would resemble behavior similar to people who treat Astrology/ Horoscopes as anything other than mindless entertainment.


    Ultimately, the majority of players will be fine with an attempt to emulate another map’s control balance, an attempt to tweak the balance slightly from another map, or even an attempt to try something totally new. You will never make everyone happy, so don’t ever sweat the negative feedback. Try to do what feels right based on the inspiration you have, and so long as you choose to learn from what proved to be a bad idea (as Valar did numerous times,) you will never experience an outright failure. It’s also not a bad idea to compile a few slightly different versions of you map all at the same time in order to allow your play-testers to see what the positive/negative aspects of a certain idea would be ‘back-to-back’ in a single sitting.



    ------------------------------------------------------

    Section 3: Load-out Guidelines

    ------------------------------------------------------

    Since this post is already too damn long (as is the inherent nature of The New Guy,) I decided to post the ‘formulas’ I push on people in a separate thread which can be found here: https://www.everythingfps.com/topic.php?id=1045


    So … uh … yeah, my posts tend to be long and daunting about mapping stuff, but this usually makes for a positive work environment (no pun intended.) Whatever map you attempt to make, rest assured that I will provide plenty of feedback and take your work very seriously. I look forward to anything & everything you choose to provide.


    And thank you again for making an attempt at braving this unique yet unfathomably wild & untamed Arena Shooter.

Viewing posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)

You must be logged in to reply. Login Here